Sunday, January 22, 2012

MACABRE


Most cynical internet denizens will tell you that the resurgence of 3D is a mere gimmick, meant to drag more people to theaters and jack up ticket prices. (I am one of those cynical people.) Average movie-goers seem to be agreeing, with a resounding “I paid five bucks extra for this crap? I could have had nachos!”
3D has come and gone throughout film history, and each time we come to the same general conclusion: We kinda don’t like it. Until we have some kind of full immersion films (and would they even be films at that point?) we’ll probably never be satisfied.
When 3D movies fell apart the first time, Hollywood just went back to doing what they had been doing before the 3D boom: Trying to make good movies. One man was not satisfied, though. William Castle, director and producer of ridiculous B-movies, had a vision. He wanted to make every single one of his films into a spectacle event (much to the annoyance of theaters that booked his movies) that drew the masses to the cinema for the experience. Here are six of his most notorious gimmicks.

6. Life Insurance Policies for the Audience

Castle’s 1958 film, Macabre, features a man trying to find his daughter, who has been buried alive, before she suffocates. You may have seen this exact same plot in 90% of horror movies and in at least one episode of every TV show ever, and it was about as thrilling then as it is now. That didn’t stop Castle from laying it on thick in the movie’s promotion though.
Every audience member was given an insurance certificate from Lloyd’s of London guaranteeing a $1,000 payout if they “died of fright.” (Now you’re lucky to get a box of Red Vines at the movies for $1,000.) Of course, according to the trailer, it didn’t cover people with heart conditions or suicides. Really? What kind of movie were they preparing these people for? “Fuck walking out, honey. I’m just gonna kill myself. Tell the kids I love them!”

5. Emergo!

House on Haunted Hill, starring the ever-awesome Vincent Price, is one of the classics of the B-horror genre. Five people are invited to Vinnie’s big, fancy mansion and offered $10,000 if they can stay the night. Of course, it’s really all a big, overly-complicated scheme to catch his wife and her lover trying to kill him or something, because apparently that’s how people settle infidelity disputes in William Castle Land.
Toward the end of the movie, there’s this way schlocky scene where Vincent Price’s character uses a fake skeleton on puppet strings to make it chase his wife into a vat of acid. Seriously. That actually happens. Watch it if you don’t believe me. The “Emergo!” part came during this scene, where the skeleton slowly shambles toward the doomed woman. In some theaters, Castle had rigging installed that would hoist an inflatable, glow-in-the-dark skeleton above the audience. Because that apparently scared people over the age of five in 1959.

4. Percepto!

After the success of House on Haunted Hill, Castle followed up with another Vincent Price-led film called The Tingler, which sounds more like a really terrible wrestler than anything frightening. Note that the trailer even says “Guarantee: The Tingler will break loose in the theater while YOU are in the audience.” So, you know, if you really want to sell stuff, promise your customers that terrible things will happen to them if they buy your product. The ad writer probably followed that up with, “Guarantee: An elephant will break loose and fuck you while YOU are at the zoo.”
In the film, Price plays a doctor who discovers a parasite that lives in every human’s spine and feeds on fear, which he calls a Tingler. If the host doesn’t scream, the Tingler will kill them. One of Vincent Price’s buddies, whose wife is deaf and mute, uses this to his advantage and kills her… because, again, William Castle apparently had a rough childhood. Vincent Price extracts the Tingler from her corpse, which later escapes his lab and gets loose in a crowded movie theater. At this point, the screen was meant to go black and a voice would announce that the Tingler is loose in the theater the audience is in, and would encourage everyone in the theater to scream and try to kill it. Some seats would even vibrate, thanks to surplus airplane de-icers that Castle must have picked up on the cheap. When the audience had “subdued” the Tingler, the movie resumed. That’s it. Why’s it called Percepto? Because making your ass buzz is what it takes to make you perceive that you should have sat somewhere else, I guess.

3. Illusion-O

For William Castle’s next film, 13 Ghosts, he used a gimmick inspired by 3D movies that he called “Illusion-O,” which sounds like the worst stage magician name ever. With Illusion-O, each audience member was given a cardboard viewer that resembled red/blue 3D glasses.
The idea behind Illusion-O was that the ghosts showed up throughout the film in blue. Therefore, if you were a huge wuss, you could look through the blue side of the viewer and you wouldn’t be able to see the ghosts. If you looked through the red side, the ghosts showed up more strongly. And if you tossed your Illusion-O in the garbage on the way in, well, you could see the ghosts fairly easily without the stupid thing anyway.

2. The Fright Break

In 1961, William Castle released Homicidal, which was essentially a Psycho knock-off. A woman and her brother have to deal with the brother’s crazy wife. The big marketing piece for this film was what Castle called “the fright break.” At the film’s climax, the movie paused for 45 seconds to allow any patrons who were too scared to watch the rest of the film a chance to get a full refund. Well hey! What a nice guy! (I guess he didn’t account for people who just thought the movie sucked.) Except if you did take the refund, you had to walk to a “Coward’s Corner” in front of the whole audience, who were encouraged to laugh at your pansy ass the whole way.
Another big part of the marketing was Castle going around in ads for the film and making people promise not to give away the film’s big surprise. Before the 1960s, it was totally customary for people to spoil movies to their friends. (Now we have ubiquitous access to just about any information you could want and it’s a cardinal sin to do so.) For this film, Castle specifically disallowed people to be seated in the theater 15 minutes before the twist ending. Even in the trailers, Castle says that if you spoil the movie, your friends will kill you, which is pretty messed up. Then he smiles, points directly at the camera, and says “…and if they don’t, I will.” Holy shit, man. That’s like Mickey D’s telling customers that if they reveal what the special sauce is, they’re gonna get Ronald McDonald’s clown shoe up their ass. (Note that I am specifically not spoiling the film for you because I don’t want some sort of zombie William Castle crashing through my door later.)

1. The Punishment Poll

Later in 1961, Castle released Mr. Sardonicus, an 1800s period piece about a man who tries to rob his dad’s grave for a lottery ticket and ends up horribly disfigured as a result. You see, he’s given the face of his father’s badly decayed corpse (despite the fact that his father’s been dead for only a few days at that point, so maybe his dad looked like Hugh Hefner before he died or something). Like Homicidal, one of the promotional techniques Castle used was to conceal much of the plot. More specifically, the face of Mr. Sardonicus isn’t show in any of the promotional material. Ostensibly, it’s to not terrify people, but come on, how bad can the guy look?
Holy shit! It’s like an Enzyte commercial on shrooms. Apparently he decided not to screw around on the whole “horror” thing this time.
The film’s audience participation gimmick was in the form of placards handed out to the audience before the film started. Each featured a glow-in-the-dark thumbs-up or thumbs-down, which the audience held up in the direction of the projector booth at the end of the movie to “decide” Mr. Sardonicus’s fate. Reportedly, two endings were shot– one in which Mr. Sardonicus was given a cruel fate and another in which he was cured of his disfigurement. Legend states that the merciful ending was never shown because the audience always voted for the punishment ending (it doesn’t help that William Castle, in full period garb, emphasizes how Sardonicus should “suffer… and suffer… and suffer.” To be fair, movie theater audiences can be kinda full of huge bastards). 
In reality, though, the reel doesn’t change between the poll and the ending scene, so it’s almost certain that no alternate ending was shot, and no one has found any footage from one to this day. So, really,William Castle was just a huge cynic who thought that humanity loves to be horrible and judgmental. What a guy!

CRITERION 550


Criterion FilesBob Rafelson’s highly underrated The King of Marvin Gardens(1972) works as something of an unofficial sequel to his beloved previous film and the rightful centerpiece of the BBS Story, Five Easy Pieces (1970). After the “farcidelia” of Head, Rafelson’s second film could not be further from its opposite in tone, aesthetics, and overall relation to the counterculture, whose narrative absence is used to great effect in the latter film.
It wasn’t until Rafelson’s third film as director that his identity as a filmmaker started to solidify through his continued exploration of themes shared between films. Like many filmmakers of the New Hollywood generation, Rafleson possessed symptoms of the self-conscious auteur, but the similarities between Five Easy Pieces andThe King of Marvin Gardens go far beyond surface connections that denote a consistent cinematic personality behind the camera in terms of themes and style, but instead point to a rare kind of filmmaker altogether during New Hollywood or any era.

Rafelson’s America

New Hollywood was arguably one of the most class-conscious eras in movie studio history, stacked with relentless depictions of strife at the hand of a competitive and unforgiving modern landscape in pantheon mainstays like Midnight Cowboy (1969) and Taxi Driver (1976). But rather than explore the violent portrayals of suffering attendant in these more famous films, Rafelson’s work is gentler in that it instills neither pity for nor fear of his characters. Rafelson’s protagonists struggle, but seeing them as victims requires a condescension and distance that the filmmaker clearly isn’t interested in.
There’s a remarkable specificity to working class life in Rafelson’s films. As Mark Le Fanu points out in his essay accompanying the set, there is a remarkable adaptability to geography present in Rafelson’s work, and with these changes in location his specificity is consistent, making viewers feel as if the two hours they share with these characters are simply a drop in the bucket in which we are given brief access to one moment in a fully detailed and complex life. Whether journeying from the sparse vistas of the southwest to the beautiful foggy woods of the Pacific northwest in Five Easy Pieces or traversing the crumbling icons of the northeast Atlantic coast in The King of Marvin Gardens, Rafelson embeds a degree of familiarity that one would think he grew up in every corner of America and could thus attest to a vision of an entire nation with autobiographical understanding.

Atlantic City By Way of New Hollywood

The films produced by BBS weren’t simply standout films made by Americans through a major American studio during a renaissance in American filmmaking, but they were films profoundly about America. A blatantly obvious point, to be sure, but one that becomes rather meticulous when considering what the set accomplishes as a whole, as the film featured within are both specific and exhaustive in their inspection and critique of America. Each of these films utilize the specific space of their story to comment on profound changes shaping the country as a whole.
The Atlantic City captured by The King of Marvin Gardens might make for a footnote in some record of the city’s history, but never a major chapter, so it’s compelling that the city’s strange interval period is captured here with such a strict attention to its dilapidated attractions, its empty restaurants, its noisy rides, and its dusty hotels occupied by old men and women hanging on to its (and their) glory years. The Atlantic City of 1972 was defeated by competing sources of leisure, far from its populated height in previous decades portrayed nostalgically by premium entertainment like Boardwalk Empire. This is also the Atlantic City that wasn’t quite how we know it today, as the Las Vegas of the northeast, as gambling had not yet been made legal to save it from slow and embarrassing ruin.
Admittedly, Rafelson likely had no idea what would come of Atlantic City, but one can’t help but be fascinated in getting the chance to peek at this historical interval, with Rafelson infatuated with depicting every corner of it, and the subtle, low-rent beauty his characters share that encapsulate for the film (as indicated by its titular Monopoly allegory) a continued tragedy playing out in the futile grasps for a dead American Dream depicted here.
But looking back at this interval period of Atlantic City also provides the opportunity to similarly look back at New Hollywood not as a creative peak in American studio filmmaking, but as itself a brief and strange interval between one dominant form and another. As Atlantic City is reduced to remnants of its former self, with its memories lingering as ghosts in the cracking walls, the glory of Hollywood’s old studio system lingered through the late 1960s and the 1970s. After all, what we think of as New Hollywood hardly represented the only types of movies being made at this time. Actors and filmmakers from the old era still worked, but the magic was gone. So these new, young, challenging artistic voices emerged not as a replacement, but to take the reigns until something shiny and new inevitably took hold. And in 1975 and 1977, with the release of Jaws and Star Wars, something new did. The first films of Spielberg and Lucas might more accurately be termed New Hollywood instead, for they embodied the renewed version of the old implied in this term. What BBS accomplished has no term that captures it completely.
That BBS (and, by association, New Hollywood at large) fell apart was less a story tragically cut short than it was an event clearly inevitable to all involved. This is why the team involved with BBS was so prolific in such a short period of time. They knew it was a rare opportunity that likely wouldn’t last. While many filmmakers and performers survived and even flourished from the mid-late seventies blockbuster era that has since exponentially defined Hollywood’s narrow contemporary function, the transition out of the New Hollywood interval was not without its casualties. For example, Hal Ashby’s career — and life — ended only a few years after the 1970s did. While Rafelson’s fate wasn’t quite as tragic or dramatic, he certainly peaked early as this era was remarkably suited for his aesthetic and thematic sensibilities. Instead of bemoaning the loss of the brief New Hollywood era, understanding this time instead as a brief interval makes me thankful that the right people just so happened to be making films during this brief window of opportunity in American film history.

The Book is Dead

While Bruce Dern’s Jason Staebler could very well be an incarnation of Five Easy Pieces‘ Bobby Dupea somewhere down the road, Rafleson made the shrewd decision of giving Jack Nicholson the less charismatic role, as his nebbish and reserved artistic intellectual brother David, a character directly against Nicholson’s type in this or any other decade. David uses his late-late-night radio show as the medium for his own autobiography because, as he expresses to himself by himself in Atlantic City, that nobody reads and the book is dead:
“Goodbye written word. I have chosen this medium to talk about my life. Not because it is worthy, but because it is hopefully, comically unworthy.”
Nicholson’s justification for radio as an art form sums up the quintessential “Rafleson character” as an antihero who needs to be onscreen precisely because he is an unworthy protagonist. But more importantly, it encapsulates the cruel nature the passage of time has to most art. David’s radio show is broadcast to almost no listeners and is likely not recorded. Rather than use the implied “permanence” of the written word David has chosen the ephemeral route, allowing his art to both exist and not exist in the same moment. David knows his art will likely be forgotten if noticed at all, but that doesn’t mean it’s any less worthy of being made. This may have been the mantra of those who took incredible risks at BBS, but thankfully their art wasn’t lost in the soundwaves.

Saturday, January 21, 2012

ALICE 22

Which Side by Bakanekonei

Alice in Wonderland by hop2pop

Alice’s Tea Party by skyfinch

Alice by guterrez

Steam Punk Alice in Wonderland by rebelakemi

alice in wonderland by mirai

Alice in Wonderland by ritchat

Alice in Wonderland by kevichan


THE HOST

Headphones on. DVD player loaded. Blank page open. That’s right, folks. It’s another edition of Commentary Commentary, our weekly look at a film’s commentary track and all the amazing anecdotes and discernment that come with it. This week we’re going international for the first time here in Commentary Commentary. We’re headed all the way to South Korea and all the way back to 2006. Not exactly sure which of those two settings are further away, but we have them right here on this pressed, metal disc.
This week we’re listening to Bong Joon-ho‘s commentary on his monster movie, The Host. Does he end up revealing in it how much he hates everything America stands for? Spoiler alert: he doesn’t, but I’m sure this article isn’t going to help matters. So take a look at what I learned. I suddenly have a craving for Kimchi and Soju.

THE HOST (2006)

Commentators: Bong Joon-ho (director, screenwriter), Tony Rayns (long-time friend of the director), the soothing sounds of a giant fish with legs vomiting up the bones of dozens of victims (I no longer want Kimchi)
  • The opening scene was inspired by a true event. In 2000, a mortician in Seoul under the employment of the US Air Force ordered his workers to dump embalming fluid down the drain. All in all, 120 liters were washed into the Han River raising the toxicity level. When Bong saw this case, he felt it would make a suitable beginning to his monster story. Details in the opening scene, the mortician being obsessed with dust on the bottles to be precise, were based on the actual case.
  • Bong remembered Scott Wilson from 1984’s A Year of the Quiet Sun and 2003’s Monster. Though the actor had a small role in those films, the director felt the actor had a dignity that was needed for the role of the US doctor.
  • A little South Korean geography, the Han River runs right through the middle of Seoul, and it is very broad. Many residents of the city have to cross the river several times a day. Bong also mentions there are suicides involving people jumping into the Han River every day.
  • Bong Joon-ho felt that in many monster movies, it’s always the scientist or the muscle-bound hero who saves the day. He wanted the heroes of his film to be everyday people, namely a dysfunctional family. He took the same approach with his previous film, 2003’s Memories of Murder, in which the police investigating the serial killer case were “stupid.” Rayns mentions this is common in Bong Joon-ho’s films, the idea of a lower to middle class character who is on a downward track. The director mentions with these characters he can bring out the humanity in them, whereas the typical superhero types don’t bring out much real drama.
  • Bong is always on the lookout for new actors and actresses to work with. However, due to the visual work and special effects on in The Host, he decided to work with actors he had previously worked with. This allowed him to put all his focus and stress level to the visual look of the film.
  • The blond hair with black roots showing through on Song Kang-ho was a deliberate choice to make the character appear lazy and not very bright.
  • Bong Joon-ho refers to actor Byeon Hie-bong as his “father in the industry.”
  • Rayns mentions the tradition of withholding the monster in typical monster movies and the fact that Bong completely breaks this tradition. Bong Joon-ho mentions how much he hates this tradition and jumped at the chance to show his creature fully and early. This also got that aspect of the film out of the way so the audience could focus on the impact the creature has on the family.
  • Rayns recollects visiting Bong’s production offices and seeing dozens of potential creature designs hanging on the wall. The director mentions the tail and the mouth as the most important part of the creature design. He and his creature designer wanted the monster here to be different from those typically found in Western cinema. Most notably, he didn’t want his creature to look like a dragon. Pictures of mutated and exotic fish were used to ultimately create the look of the monster in The Host. Bong Joon-ho also wanted a creature whose look worked in harmony with that of actor Song Kang-ho.
  • There was pressure on Bong Joon-ho to include less full-on shots of the creature’s face and more in profile, as these would be cheaper to do. Likewise, due to the film’s budget, several planned shots of the creature had to be reordered or scrapped altogether. Around 180 creature shots were planned at the storyboard level, but the director had to reduce it to around 120.
  • “Once he was a student activist, but now he’s a loser.” – Bong Joon-ho on the character Nam-il played byPark Hae-il. Rayns also mentions the bottle Nam-il is carrying when he enters the funeral hall is a bottle of Soju, a Korean form of vodka made from sweet potatoes. The Soju bottle is also a foreshadowing to Nam-il carrying the Molotov cocktails at the end of the film.
  • The idea of a viral outbreak was one more dissimilarity between Bong Joon-ho’s film and typical monster movies. His first idea when writing the script was mainly to focus on the family element. He wanted to include the predicament of the family being hunted by the government that was also searching for the monster. “The family doesn’t want to fight with the monster. They have no interest in the monster. Their only interest is focused on their own daughter,” says Bong Joon-ho who sees this movie as sort of a kidnapping movie.
  • The idea of the monster being able to swing from its tail and its agility was inspired by the location alone. Bong Joon-ho knew that based on the surroundings, the monster would have to be able to move like it does in order to move around underneath the bridge.
  • The concept of bribing in South Korea is generational. Bong Joon-ho mentions it is typical for someone of Byeon Hie-bong’s generation to try and bribe someone. “Did you have to bribe anyone to make this film?” asks Rayns. “My producer,” responds Bong Joon-ho.
  • “The mobile phone changed our script writing,” Bong Joon-ho remarking on how the device plays such an important part in modern film and real life alike.
  • Regarding the story on the news in the film about the nurse wanting to sue Gang-Du for injuries she sustained during the family’s escape from the hospital, Bong Joon-ho remarks how this is a “social joke.” He also mentions many jokes and much of the humor in the film comes about naturally or automatically while he writes the screenplay as opposed to them being deliberately included.
  • Most of the underground settings in The Host are real locations found underneath the Wonhyo Bridge. The only set built for these underground locations was the creature’s shelter.
  • Money and eating are two important motifs Bong Joon-ho points out in The Host. Throw in a crazy big monster, and what else do you really need?
  • Bong Joon-ho mentions his 2004 short film Sink and Rise as a short test for The Host. Similar locations and actors are used.
  • The idea of Seori comes up. Bong Joon-ho notes it is nearly impossible to translate to Western society. It is a looter culture in Korea of young kids stealing food, typically melons of some kind, not as a criminal act but as a mischievous act. If the children were caught, they would not be arrested or turned into the authorities but scolded for their actions. Bong Joon-ho included this phrase in the film to create something of a connection between Gang-Du and the two boys, as if he sees something of himself in them. This is important at the end of the film when Gang-Du goes to the younger brother after the creature has been killed.
  • Bong Joon-ho felt it important to give the entire family, daughter included, one last moment together. Hence the inclusion of the ghost image during the scene with them eating in the shack.
  • Five companies were involved to execute the creature.
  • Byeon Hie Bong’s character of the grandfather allowing the creature to trample him is Bong Joon-ho’s way of the character accepting that he did everything he could to save his family. It is a weight he passes on to his children now that he has allowed himself to be killed.
  • The director decided to incorporate footage from the Iraq War in the film’s news footage for two reasons. First it allowed the story to progress, but it also gave Bong Joon-ho the ability to include political satire. Just as there is no virus, it’s all a rumor, there were no weapons of mass destruction.
  • The sequence involving Nam-il trying to get information from his former activist friend incorporates many stylistic choices. He and his friend meet in a dark alley indicating the opposition the had to stay underground. Likewise, when the two are talking in the elevator, Bong Joon-ho cuts between them until the concept of money is brought up. Here, he pans between the two, an indication of the friend’s forthcoming betrayal over money.
  • Rayns mentions the parallel between the way Gang-Du is treated in the hospital and how the public treats the creature. The creature is as much a victim as Gang-Du, it wasn’t born evil. Bong also mentions the moment with Gang-Du in the hospital as a turning point for the character, as the brain surgery the character goes through changes everything about him.
  • Rayns brings up Bong’s artistic personality in using black comedy as previously seen in Barking Dogs Never Bite and Memories of Murder as well as in The Host. Bong Joon-ho notes without the black comedy element he can’t do anything. “That kind of element helps the art emotions like sadness and suspense and tension, because there will be a contrast from the humor,” replies the director.
  • Bong Joon-ho brings up some of the conventional scares he includes in The Host. In his mindset, it is okay to include so many traditional scares since there is so much out of the ordinary about the creature in his film.
  • It isn’t in the context of the film, but according to Bong Joon-ho, the government in The Host believed there to be a virus at first. However they realized there was no virus but had already prepared for it by involving the media and organizing the release of Agent Yellow.
  • Bong Joon-ho refers to Lee Dong-ho, the younger of the two orphans, as the “little king” of the set, as everyone on set seemed to act to please him during shooting.
  • The design of the pod used to deploy Agent Yellow was specifically designed to resemble the look of the creature when it is first seen hanging upside down under the Wonhyo Bridge.
  • There’s a bit of a debate between Rayns and Bong Joon-ho near the end of the film regarding the “innocence” of the creature. When Rayns mentions it’s natural that the creature has to die at the end because it’s “eaten lots of people who were completely innocent by standards.” Bong Joon-ho remarks that the creature just wants to survive. “Well, sometimes you can’t let things survive,” Rayns replies.
  • The shot of Song Kang-ho grabbing the shotgun in the film’s coda uses the same framing and composition as the shot of Byeon Hie-bong grabbing the shotgun earlier in the film.
  • Though Bong Joon-ho recognizes the satire and political commentary in The Host about America, he doesn’t view it as an overtly anti-American film. Rayms remarks on the social tension between American cinema and Korean cinema. He also goes on to mention The Host as being the highest grossing film in South Korean history, that it was able to “out Hollywood Hollywood.”

BEST IN COMMENTARY

“It’s a painful process, but it’s a very creative process. I can express tension or suspense without the creature on the screen.” – Bong Joon-ho

FINAL THOUGHTS

While there is much to learn from Bong Joon-ho regarding his views and the way he put The Host together, the DVD commentary is not a very enjoyable one. Sadly, much of what we learn comes in the form of broad stroke insight into casting, the film’s narrative about family vs. the American government vs. the monster, and the design and execution of the creature. Tony Rayns brings much out of him with the questions he brings up, but the answers are hindered by Bong Joon-ho’s stilted English. It isn’t the director’s fault, mind you, but it makes for a less than completely interesting listen.
One thing it does do, though. The 12-year-old in me gave off a smirk every time the director says the word “designer.” Yeah, I know. Feel free to shoot off that angry email now.

Friday, January 20, 2012

VICTOR VECTOR

CULTURE WARRIOR 35


Culture WarriorThe Help has started a conversation that’s stretched far beyond the 137-minute confines of the film itself. And in its second week in a row atop the late-summer box office, the critical conversation surrounding the film has continued amidst (and, sometimes, against) the sleeper popularity it endures in a fashion similar to the success of the book it was based on. In interest of full disclosure, I have deliberately chosen by this point not to see The Help (perhaps a combination of my reservations against it combined with its daunting running time). However, in following the many editorials published in response to the film’s release, it oddly enough feels appropriate to comment on the conversation that the film has inspired without having seen it, as it’s a conversation that is hardly limited to the film itself.
The Help seems to represent a breaking point, the last piece of white liberal guilt that broke the clear-cut racial fantasies of Hollywood cinema’s back, so to speak. The film is bearing the brunt of a decades-long history of similarly minded feel-good studio fare about race relations. While The Help certainly has its full-throated detractors, one interesting component about the overall critical reaction to the film is that it is politically simplistic while also presenting good or perfectly competent filmmaking, carried by a couple of strong female performances at its center (which, when considering what’s lacking in terms of identity and representation in Hollywood, is itself no small miracle).
This shouldn’t be surprising. After all, Hollywood movies can be ideologically problematic and still be “good movies,” and vice versa. For all intents and purposes, enjoying a film is never contradictory to being able to recognize its problems. Does the fact that The Help is receiving mostly positive critical marks make it more of a difficult ideological bull to wrestle with, in terms of either a critic’s relationship with the piece criticized and/or helping the flocks of theatergoers understand the film’s latent regressive shortcomings? Or is any potential cinematographic quality of the film itself simply asymptomatic of the larger problem, that Hollywood has become similarly adept in manifesting the white-savior-as-liberator-of-black-oppression archetype as they are in making superhero movies or re-launching franchises?
What isn’t ambiguous, however, is what the problems of the film (and the many films of its ilk) are. Too often in Hollywood, stories of the struggles of African Americans are told through what Eric Kohn calls a “vanilla filter,”often featuring a white character occupying the prominent or co-lead performance who then acts as liberator, and their resulting enlightenment is a major emotional focus (as seen in Remember the Titans, Ghosts of Mississippi, Mississippi Burning, Glory Road, Men of Honor, Driving Miss Daisy, etc.). In short, the white character is both emancipator and benefactor. Not to say that individuals in dominant classes haven’t historically played important roles in fighting for the civil rights of minorities, but in terms of Hollywood representation the framing of these stories through white perspectives is simply disproportionate and ultimately unnecessary, making little room for the more recurrent histories of black struggle as told and experienced by those who actually did, and continue to do, the struggling.
The second corresponding issue with films like this is the implicit assertion by the simplistic narratives of such films that these struggles are, in effect, over. At Salon, Matt Zoller Seitz puts it thusly:
“Even more problematic is the overriding sense — conveyed not just in “The Help,” but in so many historical movies — that the era being depicted is tucked safely away in the past, a closed chapter, and the collective insanity that gripped society has dissipated thanks to the efforts of good-hearted people like you, the viewer.”
Seitz goes on to connect this false closure with the stark terms in which racism is defined in films like these, where a world is conveniently divided between racists and saintly liberators, where the crime of racism is beholden to a few unquestionably tainted souls and never operates in implicit or complex systemic forms, where the question of exploitation of the oppressed despite the “good intentions” of the liberator is never brought to the table, and where – perhaps most importantly of all – the audience can never examine their own potential complicity. Hollywood requires closed endings, but racism in America – despite any accepted convenient historicizing of it – is open-ended and continuous, no matter how many inspiring true stories of integrated high school sports teams who finally learn to work together are told.
Hollywood resorts to what it (unfortunately) does best: telling the same story time and again in slightly different iterations. And as a result, audiences are, in James Rocchi’s words, “coddled, not challenged.” Nothing new is learned. Instead, Hollywood bestows on us the residual comfort of the familiar. Audiences leave their theaters simply retaining these perspectives reasserted rather than developed. This particular component  makes me especially confused as to why audiences ostensibly find such films profound or revelatory, and why I specifically haven’t seen The Help: what does it have to say that most people don’t already know?
As Seitz points out, this narrative trope is hardly exclusive to Civil Rights-era storylines. Anything from Dances with Wolves to Schindler’s List to Cry Freedom fall under the same category. Admittedly, some very good movies are part of this problem to varying degrees. So the greatest offense of a film like The Help as articulated by recent editorials is not that it’s singlehandedly politically irresponsible or ideologically simplistic to an exceptional degree, the problem is that it’s in every way unexceptional, that it’s part of a trend that has become, at best, stagnant. While other Hollywood genres grow and develop through phases, films about people oppressed by the politics of identity refuse to build off the knowledge gained by their previous entries. And it doesn’t look to be getting better anytime soon.
But the conflicted critical responses to The Help evidence that the stagnation itself has gone beyond simple redundancy to the point of regression, that films like The Help should no longer be accepted as the default means of telling such stories. I’m always hesitant to embrace arguments that Barack Obama’s presidency signifies anything definitive about race relations in America, but it should at least tell us that our stories about race don’t need white protagonists.
Perhaps The Help has been given a greater weight than it alone can bear, for the implications shared between many of these editorials is that if The Help were released ten of fifteen years ago, this particular conversation may not have erupted to this degree. After all, should current movies have to pay for the sins of previous ones? However, there have been slight developments in this trope in recent years whose problems The Help seems specifically complicit to.
As you can likely gather by the titles of similar films listed before, the majority of films of this ilk are based on true stories, a fact that itself has acted as a bulwark to criticism. Despite that nothing was noted similarly in the trailers for The Help, I automatically imagined that this film too was based somewhere down the line in reality. To find out later that the film is based on a book that wasn’t published fifty years ago, but rather two years ago, was surprising to me, as is the fact that this film has been celebrated and consumed by audiences in the same manner as the previously mentioned “true stories.” These films have conditioned an accepted representation of the past to be a substitute for its own history.
It seems that The Help, then, is the logical extent of its own category: a film that is exclusively an exercise in Hollywood’s version of Civil Rights history without even the mandatory nod to a concrete basis in the real. History itself has become one with the “mythification” of that history through popular narratives. It’s a universalization of the trope that, along with present-set films like The Blind Side and Crash, marries the historical and the contemporary into the same moment, in which the experience of American race relations is a single repeated story unaltered throughout history.
While American independent cinema has, then and now, been able to address race relations with nuance and insight, in the mainstream there’s nothing to be found that addresses race relations as it is experienced today, or even as it was experienced then

WHILE MY GUITAR GENTLY WEEPS

Followers